Illustrative executive verdict
Approve with conditions
Decision: A professional firm is considering a security upgrade alongside its MSP renewal.
Recommendation: Obtain an itemized scope, reconcile license coverage, and request recovery-test evidence before approving. The documents do not support a final conclusion about duplicate charges or delivered security controls.
Commercial findings
The renewal includes a 90-day notice provision and annual escalation. Confirm the effective date, notice method, renewal term, and adjustment basis with the provider and counsel.
License review
Microsoft 365 Business Premium includes Defender for Business. A third-party endpoint line item may overlap, but may also include different capabilities or managed monitoring. Request its SKU, coverage, service scope, and rationale before classifying any charge as avoidable.
| Commitment | Evidence supplied | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Recovery testing | Backup job-success log | Unverified exposure: recovery-test record missing |
| MFA enforcement | “MFA active” summary | Unverified exposure: coverage and exceptions missing |
| Email authentication | DMARC p=none | Monitoring observed; enforcement and alignment need review |
Provider questions
- Please separate product licenses, configuration labor, and monitoring/response services.
- Which capabilities are included and enabled under current subscriptions?
- Please reconcile billed seats with users, service accounts, and retention requirements.
- Please provide the latest dated recovery test, its scope, result, and recovery time.
- Please provide MFA coverage and exceptions, including administrative accounts.
- Please confirm renewal dates and propose clearer notice and adjustment terms.
Sign-off: Actual briefs identify the operational reviewer, CISSP security reviewer, date, documents, limitations, and remaining actions.
Request your review